Lead Scoring A Colossal Painful Waste Of Time

Published on November 15, 2023 by Sawyer Middeleer

Lead Scoring A Colossal Painful Waste Of Time

As digital marketers and sales professionals, we're constantly on the quest for the holy grail of lead generation and qualification - a system that effortlessly sifts through mountains of digital chaff to reveal the golden grains of sales-ready prospects. Lead scoring, in theory, is a marketer's dream come true, offering a way to prioritize leads based on their perceived value. However, it has metamorphosed into a colossal and sometimes painful waste of time, bogging down sales teams with often inaccurate and arbitrary numbers. But why has this become the case when it promises so much potential?

The Lead Scoring Promises

The allure of lead scoring is well-founded in its intent. It promises to deliver a quantitative framework to evaluate leads, assigning numeric values based on specific behaviors or levels of engagement. The idea is that by tracking a lead's interactions with your content, website, or sales representatives, you can determine their sales-readiness and pass them to sales at the optimal time.

Lead scoring models typically encompass two dimensions: demographic information (firmographics in B2B) that aligns with your ideal customer profile, and behavioral information that indicates interest or engagement. By setting up this system, businesses aim to streamline their sales process, target the right people, and increase conversion rates through timely and relevant engagement.

The Pitfalls of Lead Scoring

Despite the rosy promises, the reality of lead scoring systems has left much to be desired. Here's a dive into why lead scoring can become a nightmare instead of a sales dream.

1. Complex and Resource-Intensive Setup

Creating a lead scoring system requires meticulous planning, input from multiple departments, and a deep understanding of your customer's journey. Most painfully, it requires continuous tweaking and adjustments to align with changing market dynamics and customer behaviors.

2. Lack of Standardization Across Channels

Leads engage across multiple channels, but assigning consistent scores across these touchpoints can be maddeningly complex. What scores should you assign to an email open versus a social media engagement, for instance? The lack of standardization can make your lead scoring model subjective and unreliable.

3. Data Inaccuracy and Overload

Businesses often drown in data, yet starve for insights. Lead scoring models are no different. They rely on a barrage of data points, many of which are prone to inaccuracy or irrelevance. This can lead to a distorted view of a lead's true interest or suitability for your product.

4. Changing Buyer Behaviors

Buyer behaviors are constantly evolving, but lead scoring models tend to remain static. A once-reliable indicator of sales-readiness might now be a common casual interaction that bears no correlation with purchase intent.

5. Score Decay and Maintenance Headaches

Leads change jobs, lose interest, or get new challenges to solve - which means their scores should decay over time. Managing this decay, however, is a maintenance headache that can result in outdated scores and missed opportunities.

6. Wrong Focus: Scoring Over Engaging

In worst-case scenarios, businesses become so fixated on the mechanics of scoring they neglect the art of engaging. Automation overshadows human intuition, and numbers take precedence over narrative.

Alleviating the Lead Scoring Pain

Is it time to abandon lead scoring altogether? Not necessarily. Instead, businesses should revisit and reconfigure their approach to make it work for them in today's marketplace.

Reevaluate and Simplify

Starting with a reevaluation of your lead scoring system can uncover unnecessarily complicated elements. Simplify your model by focusing on the most predictive behaviors and demographic attributes. Use historical data to determine which factors genuinely correlate with closed deals.

Embrace Predictive Lead Scoring

Predictive lead scoring uses artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning to analyze large sets of data and identify patterns that humans might miss. By leveraging AI, you can continuously refine your scoring model with far less manual intervention.

Regular Audits and Cross-Departmental Collaboration

Regularly auditing your lead scoring system to ensure its ongoing relevance is key. Additionally, alignment between marketing and sales is critical. Ensure both departments agree on what constitutes a qualified lead and that feedback loops are in place to refine scoring criteria.

Implement Lead Scoring with a Human Touch

No matter how sophisticated your lead scoring system is, it's important not to lose sight of the human element. Encourage your sales team to apply their own judgment and intuition when evaluating leads.

Align Lead Scoring with Buyer Personas and Journey

Customize your scoring model to reflect specific buyer personas and tailor the journey stages that your prospects move through. This granularity helps ensure that you're nurturing leads in a way that resonates with their particular needs and progress.

Use Technology to Your Advantage

To mitigate the frustration of maintaining complex scoring models, turn to modern technology solutions like Aomni. Platforms like these can help analyze data, update scores in real-time, and predict the next-best action for each lead.

In Conclusion

The truth is, while lead scoring has often become laborious and flawed, with careful application and modern technological aids, it can still be an incredibly powerful tool for optimizing your sales process. It's time to break away from the one-size-fits-all model and embrace a more dynamic, intelligent approach to evaluating leads. Doing so can transform the painful tedium of lead scoring into a finely tuned mechanism that drives sales success and business growth.

Take your workflow to the next level